Tuesday, July 17, 2012

Alexandra and Ivar from O Pioneers!

I feel sorry for barefoot Ivar, who cannot fit in and feels isolated in a country where they do not tolerate unusual people.  This is from the second section of O Pioneers!

Alexandra frowned. "Ivar, I wonder at you, that you should come bothering me with such nonsense. I am still running my own house, and other people have nothing to do with either you or me. So long as I am suited with you, there is nothing to be said."
Ivar pulled a red handkerchief out of the breast of his blouse and wiped his eyes and beard. "But I should not wish you to keep me if, as they say, it is against your interests, and if it is hard for you to get hands because I am here."
Alexandra made an impatient gesture, but the old man put out his hand and went on earnestly:-"Listen, mistress, it is right that you should take these things into account. You know that my spells come from God, and that I would not harm any living creature. You believe that every one should worship God in the way revealed to him. But that is not the way of this country. The way here is for all to do alike. I am despised because I do not wear shoes, because I do not cut my hair, and because I have visions. At home, in the old country, there were many like me, who had been touched by God, or who had seen things in the graveyard at night and were different afterward. We thought nothing of it, and let them alone. But here, if a man is different in his feet or in his head, they put him in the asylum. Look at Peter Kralik; when he was a boy, drinking out of a creek, he swallowed a snake, and always after that he could eat only such food as the creature liked, for when he ate anything else, it became enraged and gnawed him. When he felt it whipping about in him, he drank alcohol to stupefy it and get some ease for himself. He could work as good as any man, and his head was clear, but they locked him up for being different in his stomach. That is the way; they have built the asylum for people who are different, and they will not even let us live in the holes with the badgers. Only your great prosperity has protected me so far. If you had had ill-fortune, they would have taken me to Hastings long ago."

Monday, July 16, 2012

George Herbert Walker Bush quotation

"If anyone tells you America's best days are behind her, they're looking the wrong way."

We saw this at a Veteran's memorial in Winona.  I thought it was pertinent.

Poetry and the Sublime

We are currently in Winona, MN.  Although it is a little dry here in places, the river is running and I find it extremely beautiful.  I have tried to express how I feel, but it always comes out sounding trite.  I have been reflecting on why poetry and music typically expresses feelings better than prose.  I think that all the oft-cited reasons, such as the inadequacy of our vocabulary to express subtleties of emotion, are probably partially true.  I think another factor is that people cannot really listen to each other.  As soon as somebody starts talking, we start hearing what we think the person is saying rather than what is actually being said.  This is probably why it frustrates people if they can't figure out what "box" to put you into.  Are you a liberal?  A conservative?  A reactionary?  People always want to filter what is said, to reduce it to something familiar.

Poetry has the ability to throw you off guard.  I think this is why the best poetry is not easily accessible; if you have to take the time to understand it, it can get past your filter and into your heart.

I think this is why Willa Cather wanted to separate her art from her politics.  As soon as she is labeled a "reactionary" for describing a romantic image of the past, then we can shut off what she is really saying. My opinion is that Willa Cather really wanted to capture, as well as possible using the limited palette of the English language, is a sense of the sublime.  This is why her writing is so apt to use elaborate descriptions of romantic images, such as sunsets and horizons.

In addition, I am not sure that her politics are very well understood, either.  I hope to look into it when we travel to Red Cloud.  Political thought is always provisional, and can seem superficial to people in different contexts.  It seems somebody as sophisticated as Cather could not be adequately described using simplistic labels of any kind.

I also don't think her vision of the past is all that romantic, to be honest.  Her characters seem to be alienated and helpless, particularly the most sympathetic of her characters.  There are three suicides in My Antonia, one of them was beloved Mr. Shimerda.  

I found Cather's valedictory speech, delivered when she was sixteen, to be very insightful and reflective.  In this speech, she clearly has her heart in the future; she has a clear picture of how people can prepare themselves to maintain a sensitivity to the divine in a world where accepted views are being challenged by the  advances in science.  

Jonathan Swift wrote, "When a true genius appears among you, you will know him by this sign, that the dunces are all in confederacy against him."  I think this describes what has happened to Willa Cather.  It is too bad that academic interpretation of literature is shaped so much by intellectual trends.  I think that there is so much pressure for professors to publish that they almost need to hang their reputation on movements, particularly if they lack the creativity to come up with new perspectives on their own.  The problem with applying a critical approach to interpret somebody's writings, particularly writings as deep as Cather's, is that it is intellectually limiting.  That is not to say that Freudians, for example, don't have anything to say about literature.  It is true that we should try to see the literature beyond the filters we use.  

Sunday, July 15, 2012

Reflections on other sites

They are in a severe drought in the Midwest, but I have been quite surprised at how green everything is compared to Arizona.  Oklahoma seemed particularly lush, but they have had some rain recently.

In addition to the sites I have written about, we visited numerous other interesting places.  At first, I thought they were not important to my overall investigation, but now that I reflect, I am seeing a theme.  We saw the Cadillac Ranch near Amarillo, a giant cross with surrounding statue park depicting the Stations of the Cross in Groom, TX, and the Precious Moments chapel near Carthage, MO.

What makes something sacred to us?

I started this trip hoping to learn how we preserve the of Willa Cather and Laura Ingalls Wilder.  The common theme, as I thought, was a view of the pioneer as emblematic of the good life of self-reliance and perseverance.  The other theme that arises is the way in which people turn people into something more than people.  We live in a literary culture, and the religions that shape Western Civilization are scriptural religions.  In the end, what we will preserve of these people is their writings.  Who knows what Homer's house looked like?  In the meantime, however, the people themselves become transcendent personages based largely on the fact that the words they wrote resonate with people.

In the Midwest, preservation of history is carried out with a great deal of fervor.  It sometimes seems that people have their heads in the past.  The towns here look old, and you get a feeling that they see their greatness as based on what happened in the past.  While it seems very important for people to interpret the past to make it consonant with their current political realities (as in Confederate-friendly Carthage emphasizing Union supporter Molly Hood and her "petticoat flag"), but there really is not the sense of future that we have in Arizona. 

Cadillac Ranch

 Precious Moments Chapel





Springfield, Illinois

Gerardus van der Leeuw thought that the feeling of awe that people feel in the presence of great personages is the basis of all religion.  Visiting Springfield, I think that van der Leeuw may have been onto something.  Abraham Lincoln is treated with a respect here that it is no exaggeration to call "worship."  I myself felt a mystic rush as we approached his home. 

Lincoln moved to Springfield at the age of 28, just about halfway through his life.  He was a successful circuit lawyer, and the house is very nice.  Many of the possessions are original to the house.  I don't know why it makes a difference, but to look at something that Lincoln actually owned is different than looking at a replica. 

In Japan, the shrine and all the buildings at Ise are taken down and replaced stick by stick every twenty years.  Is this the same shrine of the ancestors?

We visited Lincoln's tomb, which I found to be surprisingly elaborate.  Would people have built such a structure for a mere human?  Although some people seemed to be having fun outside the tomb itself, the feeling inside was one of deep reverence.

I have to wonder how a person becomes a god.  In Springfield, the most common interpretation of the significance of Lincoln is that anybody can become president.  He had very little formal education, but taught himself law, arithmetic and science.  He spent his childhood in a log cabin, but by the time he was in his twenties he was able to build this mansion in Springfield.  The story of Lincoln, who seems to have been a deeply troubled and conflicted individual when he was human, becomes a myth.
 


     

Friday, July 13, 2012

Hannibal Pictures

It is ironic to find this quotation in a museum in a town
dedicated to preserving the memory of Mark Twain


They say no lighthouse in the US is farther away
from any ocean




Hannibal, MO

Hannibal is where Samuel Clemens lived from ages 7 - 17.  This site is set up as a walking tour, which includes his family's house, the office where his father was Justice of the Peace, the house where the girl he modeled Becky Thatcher after lived, the "Huckleberry Finn House" where Tom Blankenship lived, and a large museum.  The boyhood home was the real highlight here.  The rooms are glassed off, and there are white statues in every one of them.  Each room has a quotation from Mark Twain.  There is an "interpretive center" that has a detailed timeline.  This museum has the feel of a museum, but it also was moving.  I think the emphasis on Twain's writings is what makes this museum work.  Twain's writings make his legacy.

They say that the raconteurs of one age become the emblems of conservatives in the next.  The Twain displayed in Hannibal does have some rough edges, but there is an attempt to emphasize the whimsical side of his personality and cover up the subversive edge.  There is very little mention of Twain's views on religion, for example.  The upside is that Twain's writings are so well known that it is not possible to sanitize him completely.  

The absolute highlight of this trip was a performance of Twain's A True Story Told Word for Word as I Heard It by Gladys Coggswell.  This is the story of a woman whose family was broken up and sold.  Here is a link to a Youtube video of Ms. Coggswell singing "The Three-Eyed Cat."  Splendid.